About Bay Creek
Market Summary
Avg. List Price
Current Listings
Avg. Active Days on Market
Currently no active listings available that meet the criteria for market statistics calculations.
What Locals Say
Activism
Civic engagement
Hops & brews
Coffee culture
Humanitarian focused
Politically engaged
Shopping
Trendy eats
Fashion trending
Athleisure wear
market snapshot
We’ve gathered the latest market data to help you better understand what’s happening in Bay Creek.
active listings
Currently no active listings available that meet the criteria for market statistics calculations.
Recently Sold
Recently Sold Avg.
Avg. Days on Market
Recently Sold
Avg. Price/Area
Properties in Bay Creek
All
Sold
New - 4 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5373 W Glenview Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 340 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(2d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9423 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 1,244 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5246 Parkhurst Crossing, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Epique Inc, lora@wrsuccess.com, Lora Reynolds
Sold
New - 169 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(1d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
3 ba
5897 W River Chase Lane, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, derek.manis@talktotucker.com, Derek Manis
Sold
New - 70 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
5 ba
5529 W McCord Road, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, torr.patty@gmail.com, Patricia Torr
Sold
New - 220 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
6 bd
4 ba
5838 W Bayfield Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, mollyhadley@talktotucker.com, Molly Hadley
Sold
New - 672 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(2d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9422 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 340 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
5 bd
5 ba
5442 W Turnbuckle Place, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, RYAN.FOXWORTHY@TALKTOTUCKER.COM, Ryan Foxworthy
Sold
New - 340 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9434 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 939 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
3 ba
9812 Ridgecrest Lane, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Trueblood Real Estate, jamie.june@truebloodre.com, Jamie June
Sold
New - 863 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
5305 Holborn Avenue, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Trueblood Real Estate, MFialkowski@truebloodre.com, Michael Fialkowski
Sold
New - 639 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9716 Holborn Avenue, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Highgarden Real Estate, TeamBryant01@gmail.com, Sherri Bryant
Sold
New - 1,033 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5328 Covington Avenue, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, kay@kaykammeyer.com, Kay Kammeyer
Sold
New - 672 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5103 Winnsboro Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 2,375 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5025 Winnsboro Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Active
Sold
New - 4 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5373 W Glenview Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 340 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(2d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9423 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 1,244 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5246 Parkhurst Crossing, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Epique Inc, lora@wrsuccess.com, Lora Reynolds
Sold
New - 169 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(1d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
3 ba
5897 W River Chase Lane, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, derek.manis@talktotucker.com, Derek Manis
Sold
New - 70 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
5 ba
5529 W McCord Road, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, torr.patty@gmail.com, Patricia Torr
Sold
New - 220 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
6 bd
4 ba
5838 W Bayfield Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, mollyhadley@talktotucker.com, Molly Hadley
Sold
New - 672 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(2d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9422 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 939 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
3 ba
9812 Ridgecrest Lane, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Trueblood Real Estate, jamie.june@truebloodre.com, Jamie June
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Pending
Sold
New - 340 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
5 bd
5 ba
5442 W Turnbuckle Place, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, RYAN.FOXWORTHY@TALKTOTUCKER.COM, Ryan Foxworthy
Sold
New - 340 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9434 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 863 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
5305 Holborn Avenue, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Trueblood Real Estate, MFialkowski@truebloodre.com, Michael Fialkowski
Sold
New - 639 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9716 Holborn Avenue, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Highgarden Real Estate, TeamBryant01@gmail.com, Sherri Bryant
Sold
New - 1,033 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5328 Covington Avenue, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, kay@kaykammeyer.com, Kay Kammeyer
Sold
New - 672 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5103 Winnsboro Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
New - 2,375 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5025 Winnsboro Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Upcoming Open Houses
Sold
New - 169 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(1d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
3 ba
5897 W River Chase Lane, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, derek.manis@talktotucker.com, Derek Manis
Sold
New - 1,244 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5246 Parkhurst Crossing, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Epique Inc, lora@wrsuccess.com, Lora Reynolds
Sold
New - 340 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(2d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9423 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Recently Sold
Sold
- Mar 21, 2025
New - 523 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
3 ba
9078 N River Chase Lane, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: F.C. Tucker Company, derek.manis@talktotucker.com, Derek Manis
Sold
- Mar 7, 2025
New - 1,011 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
5315 Parkhurst Crossing, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Keller Williams Indpls Metro N, jennifer@onwardindiana.com, Jennifer Goodspeed
Sold
- Feb 28, 2025
New - 1,491 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9411 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Feb 28, 2025
New - 2,013 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9437 Corbett Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Feb 28, 2025
New - 1,680 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5415 W Glenview Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Feb 26, 2025
New - 1,344 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
9398 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Feb 17, 2025
New - 1,849 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5017 Winnsboro Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Feb 14, 2025
New - 1,491 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
9399 Abner Street, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Feb 11, 2025
New - 1,849 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
5035 Winnsboro Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Jan 31, 2025
New - 4,105 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
5 bd
3 ba
9329 N Bayland Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: RE/MAX Real Estate Solutions, marty@martydulworth.com, Marty Dulworth
Sold
- Jan 31, 2025
New - 3,193 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
5060 Winnsboro Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Jan 30, 2025
New - 2,859 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5019 Mountville Court, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Jan 23, 2025
New - 2,737 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
5015 Mountville Court, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Jan 9, 2025
New - 4,876 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5050 Winnsboro Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Sold
- Dec 27, 2024
New - 4,876 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
5030 Winnsboro Drive, McCordsville, IN 46055
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass Indiana, LLC, erin.hundley@compass.com, Erin Hundley
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Nearby Schools
Public
Private
No data to show right now.
N/A
Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio:
No data to show right now.
No data to show right now.
N/A
Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio:
No data to show right now.
Disclaimer: This information is provided by
Precisely
and subject to change.
Please check the applicable school district.
Transit & Commute
Estimated commute times from Bay Creek
Car-Dependent
Walkable
Very Walkable
Nearby Neighborhoods
The Admirals
5
Current Listings
Bridgewater
2
Current Listings
McCordsville
Anchorage
Lawrence Woods
Woods at Geist Overlook
1
Current Listings
Vermillion/Flat Fork
Admirals Landing
1
Current Listings
Gateway Crossing
6
Current Listings
Bradford Creek/Pointe
Breakwater
Brookston Place
2
Current Listings
E 75th St
North Woods at Geist
1
Current Listings
PPOA
Glen Cove
Geist Overlook
1
Current Listings
Highlands at Geist
Hidden Creek at Geist
Idlewood
Sandstone Crossing
Royalwood II
Sandstone Knoll
Sandstone Ridge
2
Current Listings
Oakland Woods
1
Current Listings
Feather Cove II & III
Royalwood
Reserve At Geist
Emerald Springs
11
Current Listings
Estates at Bay Creek
Brooks Park
1
Current Listings
Highland Springs South
1
Current Listings
Ambria
Timberstone Drive
1
Current Listings
Slip Anchor Ln
1
Current Listings
Westbrook at Geist
2
Current Listings
Fox Hollow at Geist
1
Current Listings
Highland Springs North
Villages at Brookside
8
Current Listings
Villages at Geist
Springs Of Cambridge
3
Current Listings
Bay Creek East Addition
1
Current Listings
Brooks Landing/Manor
1
Current Listings
Steeplechase of Fishers
Deer Crossing
3
Current Listings
Geist Woods Estates
5
Current Listings
Weatherstone
Cardinal Dr
Valleys at Geist
Canal Place
4
Current Listings
Champion Lake / Woodhaven
29
Current Listings
Intracoastal At Geist
Crystal Pointe
1
Current Listings
Geist Bay Estates
1
Current Listings